Stephen Amell and the Top 5 Celebrity Matches of All-Time

Not Included:

Butterbean vs, Bart Gunn – WrestleMania 15
Mr. T vs. Roddy Piper – WrestleMania 2

These matches were not included because they were not contested as wrestling matches. Instead, they were both boxing matches, with the first one being the only WrestleMania moment for Bart Gunn when he was knocked out by heavyweight contender Butterbean. These two are not included in the list.

Honorable Mention:

Drew Carey’s Appearance in the Royal Rumble

Since it wasn’t a typical straight forward match to be decided as pinfall, this Royal Rumble appearance by comedian and current Price is Right host won’t be counted in the rest of the rankings. Since it is one of the most memorable celebrity appearances though it earns an honorable mention on this list.

Drew Carey was entrant #5 in the Royal Rumble, and he had been previously announced as an entrant. He got into the ring while the Hardyz (Matt & Jeff) were battling on the top rope. The brothers managed to eliminate each other, leading Drew to be in the ring alone to wait for the next entrant: Kane.

After stalking around the outside of the ring, Kane entered and confronted Drew who then attempted to bribe and reason with Kane. The Big Red Machine attempted a chokeslam but was interrupted by Raven. Sensing the opportunity, Drew eliminated himself in one of the more memorable Royal Rumble moments of the 2000s.

Note: I know I said this list was based on wrestling ability, but come on. Drew Carey in the Royal Rumble was comedy gold.

Next: No. 5 Celebrity Match of All-Time