AEW: Why a Television Title would work in All Elite Wrestling

BEVERLY HILLS, CALIFORNIA - JULY 24: Cody Rhodes and Nyla Rose of "All Elite Wrestling" speak during the TNT & TBS segment of the Summer 2019 Television Critics Association Press Tour 2019 at The Beverly Hilton Hotel on July 24, 2019 in Beverly Hills, California. (Photo by Amy Sussman/Getty Images)
BEVERLY HILLS, CALIFORNIA - JULY 24: Cody Rhodes and Nyla Rose of "All Elite Wrestling" speak during the TNT & TBS segment of the Summer 2019 Television Critics Association Press Tour 2019 at The Beverly Hilton Hotel on July 24, 2019 in Beverly Hills, California. (Photo by Amy Sussman/Getty Images) /
facebooktwitterreddit

With the television debut of AEW less than a month away, let’s examine why a Television Championship would benefit the nascent promotion.

On Sept. 7, All Elite Wrestling (AEW) star/executive vice president Cody spoke with IGN’s Matt Fowler and divulged a plethora of quotes on an array of topics: the promotion’s relative grassroots origins, roster utilization, a possible extra hour on Bleacher Report Live, the show potentially oversaturating the wrestling marketplace, and his impending AEW Championship match against Chris Jericho among others.

The entire interview — which also contains plenty of passive-aggressive digs at some well-worn WWE tropes — is worth a read, but for this piece, let’s focus on what he said about perhaps creating a secondary championship, namely a television championship (emphasis mine):

"“There’s a title we’re considering,” Rhodes stated, “and it’s something people can probably guess since we’re going to be on TV, hint hint, but there are no plans for it at the moment. Right now we revolve around the AEW Championship and in D.C. we’re going to name the first ever AEW Women’s Champion, and that’s such a beautiful belt.”"

Per the former Ring of Honor (ROH) World Champion’s own words, adding a television title to the mix is more of a long-term goal than an immediate one. After all, the promotion still has its hands full with building up the World, Tag Team, and Women’s belts’ prestige. But given the steps AEW has already taken towards accomplishing those objectives, there’s no reason to believe they wouldn’t devote the same level of attention to a television title if they decide to introduce one.

In the feature, Cody declared the promotion’s intention to provide “bell-to-bell, sports-centric pro wrestling” to the masses that forwards most of its stories in the ring. That adherence to their mission statement has shone through so far; the company has shown in its first handful of shows that the wins and losses carry ramifications, thus making the matches matter.

It was this strategy that legitimized Adam “Hangman” Page as a legitimate main eventer, affirmed Jericho as a viable top-of-the-card attraction, gave fans a compelling Nyla Rose/Riho women’s title match to look forward to once their weekly show premieres on Oct. 2, and has set the table for what should be an entertaining tag team championship tournament.

As encouraging as those developments are, however, AEW still needs something for the midcarders to fight over. Something that can fill 10-15 minutes of TV time without subjugating the fans to a tedious, discursive promo segment. Something that would reify their WWE-alternative status. A television championship checks all of those boxes.

Like every promotion not run by Vince McMahon, AEW understands how important championships are for storytelling and creating new stars. Without them, the wrestlers have little incentive to fight outside of grudges, bragging rights, and money. But as talented as most of this roster is, everyone can’t get pushed to the world title scene.

A TV title would not only draw a definitive line between the midcarders and the headliners, but it would also serve as a lab to test which of the second-tier group is ready to move up the ranks. There’s also plenty of storyline gold to be mined from such a championship.

More from All Elite Wrestling

They could use the belt to establish a promising young worker like Kip Sabian or Sammy Guevara. They could put it on Page as a way to restart his momentum following his loss to Jericho at All Out. Better yet, could you imagine a workhorse like Pac replicating his WWE Cruiserweight Championship run with great match after great match on television every week? Or Maxwell Jacob Freidman strengthening his case for becoming the promotion’s centerpiece heel?

The Pac and MJF examples are the most ideal since most TV title formats lend more to accruing heel heat. AEW could book either of them, Guevara, or any other antagonist as a credible champion that exhibits enough vulnerability for the fans to buy in to the notion of them losing on any given night.

It’s a tried-and-true template: The heel champ collects an abundance of wins for months before running into a stong babyface challenger. The strong babyface contender gives them all they can handle in the title match. The heel escapes by thanks to the time limit draw, intensifying the champ’s heat and ginning up anticipation for a rematch.

It can work for babyfaces too: Having an ascending protagonist defend the title week after week against viable foes in quality matches would establish the belt as a prize that everyone wants while also grooming the titleholders for a future World Title run. It could also give the top guys who have been shuffled out of the main event something to chase in the interim, which would further boost the title’s standing in the fans’ eyes.

Historically, other companies have pulled this off with great success. Before Scott Hall threw it in the trash, all-time greats like Tully Blanchard, Arn Anderson, Dusty Rhodes, and Steve Austin made the NWA/WCW World Television Championship a cherished trophy worth fighting for, in-storyline.

In Extreme Championship Wrestling (ECW), Rob Van Dam’s 700-day reign as TV Champion — which included a legendary feud with Jerry Lynn — made him a lauded name amongst ardent fans. Jay Lethal parlayed a 537-day run with the ROH World Television Championship into a 427-day tenure as ROH World Champion, becoming the first man to hold both of those singles titles at the same time, and has been the ace of the company ever since.

Next. Anthem, owner of Impact Wrestling, acquires AXS TV. dark

These federations found success using their TV titles to create new stars. With the brain trust they have in place, AEW can do the same.

Considering what AEW has going on right now, they don’t need to create a secondary title just yet. But whenever they do, the fans should expect it to receive the same level of care and attention that the other three titles are sure to get. They’ve gotten almost everything else right, why not this?